Cash is far from meeting its Waterloo
John Foley | Published:
December 04, 2015 22:52:28
October 22, 2017 06:01:23
What do Swedish supergroup Abba, the Nigerian central bank and UK economist Andy Haldane have in common? All three are helping to speed the demise of cash. The news that banknote printer De La Rue is shuttering a quarter of its capacity amid a global note glut adds to a sense hard currency is in decline. Yet a cashless society is still some way off.
The shutdown of Malta-based printing presses by the world's biggest producer of commercial banknotes announced on December 02 may be driven by commercial rather than conceptual changes. Bank-note printing suffers from huge overcapacity. It's not that people want to hold fewer notes, but that paper currency is being replaced by more modern polymer versions.
Still, the push away from cash is building. Ireland in October encouraged shops to round up rather than give small change. The Abba museum in Stockholm only takes cards and electronic payments, because cash facilitates crimes "from murder to bicycle theft." Sweden broadly agrees. The nominal amount of currency outstanding has contracted by more than a quarter since early 2010.
Central banks have good reason to speed the transition. Bank of England economics tsar Haldane has lamented the "zero lower bound" syndrome that means policymakers cannot easily impose negative interest rates on bank reserves without savers simply switching into cash. While that's largely theoretical for now, the Bank is reviewing alternatives like digital currency.
The most persuasive case against cash is that it helps money launderers. In the UK, a 2010 study by the National Crime Agency found 90 per cent of all 500 euro note usage was by criminals. Nigeria said in 2012 it would start to move towards a cashless society. The real value of naira in circulation fell by 3.0 per cent in September, year-on-year.
Yet rich countries like Sweden and very corrupt ones like Nigeria may be the outliers. In most countries, supply of currency is growing stubbornly. In the United Kingdom, the current annual increase of 6.0 per cent in nominal terms is in line with the average since 1970. While digital alternatives will logically gain ground, the privacy, data protection and trust issues are incalculable. Cash may seem like an anachronism, but it is far from facing its Waterloo.
The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.